Quote from: badgerwarhawk on July 31, 2015, 12:24:58 PM
Being selected a pre-season All American is great but being selected a post season All American is better. In the 2014 season of the eleven players named to the offensive first team just over half (6) finished the season on the first team. One finished on the second team and two others were designated honorable mention. One other was injured and did not play. However being named to the pre-season second team seems to be the kiss of death. Of those eleven only three either moved up to the first team (1) or remained on the second team (2). The other eight were not named.
Strong programs are strong programs for many reasons not the least of which is having better players.
From a former player's perspective, being an All-American in the postseason usually puts you on the pre-season list the next year. Also being a postseason All-American in D-3 at any team level - first, second, or third still means you were one of the best.
In the spring of 1997, I played in an All-American game in New Jersy with Mike Maslowski, the UW-LX center(?), and an OLB from UW-Stout. We played at a different level than most of the other players. The national defensive player of the year in 1996 would not have made first team all-conference in the WSUC that year. The quality/level of play at that time in the WSUC was superior compared to other conferences. I wonder if their is still a large disparity in quality of play between the D3 conferences and players?