I'm hard pressed to think that Pomona-Pitzer would only get one second team All-SCIAC selection after finishing either second or third in the regular season standings. Klukas and Cohen have similar numbers but Klukas has started every SCIAC game while Cohen has come off the bench in all. I could see Klukas first team and Cohen second, or even flipped depending on Coach Kat's take.

If Pomona-Pitzer AND Whittier both have the same SCIAC record (either both win or lose Tuesday),
AND Cal Lutheran defeats Occidental,
AND Caltech defeats Redlands, THEN
#1 CMS, #2 P-P, #3 WC, #4 CLU

Explanation of tiebreaker if "crazy" scenario unfolds in reality:
Redlands 7-7 AND Cal Lutheran 7-7; (OXY is out at 6-8 since in this scenario they would lose to CLU)
UR and CLU split the head-to-head meetings (first tiebreaker)
Both went 0-2 vs. CMS (second tiebreaker)
CLU went 1-1 vs. P-P, UR went 0-2 vs P-P (third tiebreaker)

Side note: Pomona-Pitzer has to be the #2 seed for this to happen. If Whittier is the #2 seed, Redlands has the tiebreaker since the Bulldogs have a win over the Poets this season and the Kingsmen do not.

In response to cmsme's nail biter for the Stags against the Kingsmen:

I wouldn't say it was a nail biter all the way. CMS led by 17 at halftime and CLU chipped away at the lead cutting it to four points. However it did get dicey down the stretch.