I believe W & J would be the school to join the NCAC.  Can meet academic
requirement of Phi Beta Kappa Chapter.   Also, Allegheny would want them in.
Budget for athletics more in line with NCAC than Depauw.   Could be wrong, but not sure JCU has Phi Beta Kappa Chapter.

On who is coming back you show Huffman as a loss for Witt.  This remains to be seen as he technically has another year of eligibility.