Quote from: NescacOutsider on Yesterday at 01:39:35 PM

Quote from: lumbercat on November 01, 2026, 09:54:29 PM

Quote from: nescac1 on November 01, 2026, 09:35:32 AMOh, and I forgot COTY - whatever happens in the last two weeks, EJ Mills has to be the guy.  For a team with mediocre expectations to be 7-0, with five games that went down to the wire and could have gone either way but where Amherst made all the big plays down the stretch, is super impressive.  No one would say Amherst has more talent than Trinity or Wesleyan ...

Mills, like him or not, has been the best coach in this league for many years.

Congrats to Coach Mills on the lifetime achievement award. I think some might argue that Coach Devanney, and perhaps Coach Dicenzo, have been at/near the top over the past decade as the Mammoths are on pace for their best season since  2018 having averaged less than four wins a season since.

Give Mills the Trinity or Wesleyan personnel since 2018 along with their operating budgets and admissions officers and you would see more championships than either of those great programs.

Quote from: nescac1 on November 01, 2026, 09:35:32 AMOh, and I forgot COTY - whatever happens in the last two weeks, EJ Mills has to be the guy.  For a team with mediocre expectations to be 7-0, with five games that went down to the wire and could have gone either way but where Amherst made all the big plays down the stretch, is super impressive.  No one would say Amherst has more talent than Trinity or Wesleyan ...

Mills, like him or not, has been the best coach in this league for many years.

Quote from: Jonny Utah on October 28, 2026, 02:24:47 PMDon't feel like scrolling through ads for any info on this board but is Hammer out because of Health or an HR investigation? 

I guess you'd call it an HR issue Jonny. Hammer is alleged to have made an ill advised decision in his duties as the HCOF. I now have an eyewitness account of the incident and believe the allegations are accurate and he will be dismissed.
My personal speculation is he may have lawyered up and there is a legal process unfolding but based on my account of the events I think it's unlikely that he would prevail.

The esteemed leader of this forum has censored a posted account of the events so I guess this isn't Radio Free Europe.

Nothing really more than a long awaited press release from Bowdoin - with a couple of notable inaccuracies.

Coach Mac is a great guy and is proving himself as a very good coach/ DC. I'm a huge supporter from his Bates days. However to assume he is the only answer is narrow minded.

Ryans' gotta be the fall guy with the Hammer. From the bushwhacking firing of JB Wells to his folly with the ill planned overhaul of one of the most iconic and historic Football facilities in the country.
He's not a popular guy with influential alums. His stock is at its all time low amid this debacle.
Don't know if the President has a clue- can a grey Polar shed any light on her?

The bright spot on the Bowdoin staff has been DC Kyle McAllister who has been doing a fantastic job with the Bowdoin D as evidenced by a great job against Trinity last week.
I would guess the Bears may clean house but maybe not.
When they cut ties with Hammer it would seem that McAllister should be the guy to take over as HC, but he's not even the interim HC.......they named an offensive guy, a short timer in Brunswick, who is running a struggling offense as the HC.
Either way I think McAllister will be a strong candidate for openings in any program whether they let him go or not.
I think the guy on the real hot seat has to be the AD.

Quote from: ItsATuftSituation on October 25, 2026, 02:04:30 PMI just wanna take a second to shout out Tufts and their coaching staff over the last couple of weeks. It was clear that something wasn't working with the personnel so they have definitely changed where people are being deployed and it's certainly helping. I don't think this Tufts team beats Williams the way they were configured three or four weeks ago.

That's really good coaching by their staff. It also does help getting Shapiro back yesterday, it takes a lot of the pressure off of a young quarterback. I think it also gave the team a lot of confidence. Wanted to shout out Granville Anderson as well, banged up, made an absolute gutsy catch on fourth down in the final drive. Got hit, held on in traffic. He's a kid that wants to do whatever to win.

I'm excited to see how the Jumbos use this momentum into next week's game against an undefeated Amherst team. Mammoths should definitely be favored but who knows.

I wouldn't complicate things- it's the same Tufts staff that perennially encounters more problems on game day than a team with their personnel might expect. The difference is they got the best RB in the conference back from the injured list. Shapiro is a huge difference maker- not sure if NESCAC followers are aware how good this kid is.

Quote from: TheJeff on October 24, 2026, 08:20:29 PMOnce again, I think Amherst is still yet to play their best football.

Amherst does not have personnel that can match Wesleyan (or Trinity) yet they pulled off another huge win today against the Wesleyan arsenal of talent. They always mange to pull off wins like this. Once again I will attribute their success to the best HCOF in the conference year in and year out-- EJ Mills. I gotta take my hat off to him once again. I can only look at the boxscore at this point. It looks like the Mammoths outplayed a Wes team I thought was close to perfect.
Mills finds a way to win big games while the Wes publicity syndicate sometimes has a tendency to look ahead to that "final game against Trinity". Heartbreaking loss for the Cards, I was really pulling for them to get a playoff berth.  This loss makes their path a little more difficult, however, if they can beat Trinity in "that final game" I think they will be  in good shape based on my limited knowledge of the D3 playoff process and criteria.
I think Trinity will snap out of todays slumber and pound the Mammoths next week unless EJ schools Devanney the way he out schemed Dice Baby today, don't think so. Don't think Mills can pull off another coup next week against the Bantams.
I think we are looking at an undefeated Trinity club against a dangerous but unpredictable Wesleyan team in Hartford in the final game.
Lets hope we have 2 NESCAC teams in the playoffs.

Quote from: jmh21 on October 23, 2026, 05:58:57 PMWilliams has really struggled with Tufts the last few years even when having the better team on paper...even the 2021 team needed some late game magic to beat them. Hopefully that changes this year but I would be somewhat surprised if we win by double digits

Can't figure this Tufts program out---great recruiting venue, superb academic rankings, great location, university post grad program, huge enrollment....... but Coach Civetti seldom gets a sniff of the NESCAC Football title. Tufts is dominant in a number of other sports .....why the middling results in football...

Quote from: Trin9-0 on October 21, 2026, 11:42:15 AM

Quote from: Patrick Coleman on October 21, 2026, 11:25:59 AMI am guessing we don't know anything about the process for nomination for such awards.

All it says on the league website is:
"Every Monday during the season, a NESCAC Player of the Week will be selected based on information submitted by the athletic communications offices at member institutions."

I'm assuming these submissions make up the "NESCAC Weekly Honor Roll" which is published along with the Players of the Week selections. My guess is that someone, or a small group of people, at the league office looks at the Honor Roll submissions and then picks who they think is the most deserving that week. Maybe Trinity's athletics communications team doesn't provide a compelling enough case to the league office?

My guess is they get tired of picking Trinity guys over the years which is unfair but may be the case.

Colby took 2 QB transfers in the off season. One from Trinity (Tx.) and one from D1 FCS Monmouth (NJ), both felt to be better than Miller. Believe Miller has been converted to WR.

3 Milton Ma QB's who were/are good QBs have been converted to other positions in the Nescac this year. Miller WR at Colby, McHugh WR at Williams and Chase Vaughn DB at Wes.

Shapiro is probably one of 2 or maybe 3 of the most explosive offensive weapons in the league. He makes a huge difference in that offense when healthy. They are different team with him.
Not sure of the extent of his current injury.

Quote from: TheJeff on October 20, 2026, 11:10:48 AMCould Amherst go 5-4? Yes, but I don't think they've played their best football yet.

The offense is yet to piece together a complete game and Marek Hill has proved to be a legit QB with serious weapons at receiver. I felt offensive play calling restricted him vs Colby as they never went for the deep shots like they did in Middlebury. The lack of run game will hurt them against teams like Trinity and Wesleyan, but I think they can manage against Williams and Tufts.


The defense has been great to the run for the most part and seems more susceptible to the pass (concerning with Wesleyan on the horizon). As an alum, I trust Coach Mills and Coach Bussard will be able to game plan for the stronger offenses the next few weeks. With all that being said, I don't see Amherst winning a rock fight in the back half of their schedule.

Overall, they have not played a complete game on their way to 5-0. Question is: can they? Time will tell... my prediction is 7-2

Pretty easy schedule so far for Amherst. They were lucky to beat Bates and Bowdoin. Williams is the better team but anything can happen in The Game. If Shapiro is healthy they will struggle with Tufts.
By the way, what happened to Coach Ballard?

Quote from: bearsalum on October 19, 2026, 12:53:36 PMLong-time lurker, first-time commenter here, so go easy on me. Also a Bowdoin alum and longtime supporter.

I'm here to say how incredibly disappointed I am in Athletic Director Tim Ryan and Bowdoin as a whole. These student-athletes have been let down for years, and what is happening behind the scenes right now only adds to that disappointment.

Every single player on that roster earned his spot at Bowdoin. Many had opportunities to play at other outstanding academic institutions, and they chose Bowdoin. They show up every day, work hard, support one another, and represent the college with pride. What have they gotten in return? Years of inconsistent coaching, a program that has struggled to find its footing, and now a complete lack of meaningful communication from the administration during what is arguably one of the most difficult periods this program has faced.

And let's be clear, the situation surrounding Coach Hammer's leave of absence didn't develop in a vacuum. Serious concerns about the program extend well beyond wins and losses. I'm not going to speculate about confidential personnel matters or ongoing investigations, but it's fair to say there are bigger questions about leadership, accountability, and how student-athletes have been treated.

Which brings me to Tim Ryan. Where has the athletic leadership been throughout all of this? These problems didn't appear overnight. At what point does the athletic director take responsibility for recognizing that a program is in trouble and doing something about it?

To my knowledge, as of today, players and families have received little more than the announcement that Coach Hammer is on leave. No meaningful explanation of the program's direction, no publicly communicated long-term plan, and seemingly no acknowledgment of the uncertainty these young men are dealing with.

I fully understand that there are personnel matters the college cannot discuss. But that doesn't excuse the lack of communication about the future of the football program. Those are two very different things.
I feel especially badly for the juniors and seniors who have given so much to this program and may never get to experience the turnaround they deserve. And I have to wonder how many underclassmen are questioning their decision to attend Bowdoin. If I were an incoming recruit or parent, I would be asking some very difficult questions right now.
And frankly, I think the Bowdoin community deserves to know what the administration intends to do to restore confidence in this program.

Lastly, thank you to Lumbercat for recognizing the effort these players continue to put forth. This team has not quit. These men continue to show up, work hard, and compete despite everything going on around them. Some are understandably frustrated and disappointed, yet they continue to represent the school with their heads held high.

This roster has talent, including on offense! But talent alone doesn't win games. Coaching, player development, leadership, and play calling matter. Why hasn't Bowdoin invested in the experienced coaching and program support these athletes need?

These players have upheld their end of the bargain. Has Bowdoin?

I think Tim Ryan and the college owe these young men and their families a lot more than silence. I hope people stop seeing this as just another disappointing football season. Much bigger issues are at stake here.
The players deserve better. And Bowdoin needs to do better.

Finally someone comes forward and speaks for Bowdoin with a very well stated account of the situation. This has been an awful display by the Bowdoin Administration and Athletics Dept but it's nice to see a concerned supporter of the College speak up.

Last week on Twitter I saw an announcement from a recruit in California so proudly announcing his commitment to Bowdoin. A great achievement and milestone for any incoming student athlete. His first acknowledgement and thank you was to the Bowdoin HCOF (who was dismissed over a month ago). It was obvious that the young recruit from so far away was not aware of the situation in the Football Program. I'm sure things will work out well for that young man but he won't be playing for the HCOF showing on the Bowdoin website. What a terrible display of arrogance and dishonesty by the College. There are countless others like this recruit who deserve some communication and disclosure on the situation.

I know a local prospect personally who was on the verge of committing to Bowdoin. I suggested to the recruit and his parents that they contact the AD and listen to his explanation and his account of the situation before finalizing a commitment.

Is this the way the 4th ranked Liberal Arts College in the country which prides itself on openness and communication handles a situation that has potential influence on so many? The Bowdoin Athletics community deserves much better.

Considering all the turmoil in the program behind the scenes I think the Bowdoin team is competing with a lot of intensity and pride.