FB: Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association

Started by admin, August 16, 2005, 05:06:06 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

HOPEful

There goes my karma. The football board was my "safe space" lol
Let's go Dutchmen!

2015-2016 1-&-Done Tournament Fantasy League Co-Champion

HOPEful

In all seriousness though, my mind immediately goes to financial questions regarding the move.

1. How long is reasonable to expect that the football program is in the black? A lot of effort and money is going to be put into making this happen, what's the expected payoff?

2. What kind of pushback will Calvin get in the wake of all the academic and student life programs that have seen significant cuts or elimination in the last several years due to financial struggles? Calvin has been aggressively cutting programs, reducing staff, and selling real estate for a while now. Although a declining student population has played a big role too, one could argue that their financial woes began in the late 90s via construction projects and real estate purchases. Building a football stadium in many ways feels like not learning from previous mistakes, especially to students and faculty who have seen their programs gutted in recent years. A football season at Calvin in 2025 feels like a very aggressive goal, meaning that for the next 3 years minimum, a lot of time and money will be poured into something that is sure to upset the more academically focused that don't necessarily care about athletics.
Let's go Dutchmen!

2015-2016 1-&-Done Tournament Fantasy League Co-Champion

Pat Coleman

Announcing football in October 2022 and taking the field for varsity games in 2025 is not an aggressive timeline at all. The normal timeline for an announcement in the fall is to take the field two years later.

Hilbert in New York announced in November 2021 and played seven varsity games this fall. That's crazy aggressive and also probably driven by enrollment.

Schools are all looking at this enrollment cliff coming starting in 2025 and making adjustments. If Calvin needs 100 students, football is a way to get them.
Publisher. Questions? Check our FAQ for D3f, D3h.
Quote from: old 40 on September 25, 2007, 08:23:57 PMLet's discuss (sports) in a positive way, sometimes kidding each other with no disrespect.

HOPEful

Quote from: Pat Coleman on October 31, 2022, 12:17:25 PM
Announcing football in October 2022 and taking the field for varsity games in 2025 is not an aggressive timeline at all. The normal timeline for an announcement in the fall is to take the field two years later.

Fair point. I guess by aggressive, I meant in ways of infrastructure. A stadium, coaching staff, equipment, etc. It feels "aggressive" that they'd have those in place by this summer.

Is it fair to assume that in 2025 they'd have a team comprised by majority underclassmen and walk-ons? 
Let's go Dutchmen!

2015-2016 1-&-Done Tournament Fantasy League Co-Champion

Pat Coleman

That's where most programs start, yes. You could have two classes at that point, one of whom has a year of just practice/JV games/intrasquad under its belt, and one of whom is true freshmen. Often there may be a couple of key transfers, and some walk-ons from the student body at large who were already at Calvin.
Publisher. Questions? Check our FAQ for D3f, D3h.
Quote from: old 40 on September 25, 2007, 08:23:57 PMLet's discuss (sports) in a positive way, sometimes kidding each other with no disrespect.

ziggy

Quote from: HOPEful on October 31, 2022, 12:27:33 PM
Quote from: Pat Coleman on October 31, 2022, 12:17:25 PM
Announcing football in October 2022 and taking the field for varsity games in 2025 is not an aggressive timeline at all. The normal timeline for an announcement in the fall is to take the field two years later.

Fair point. I guess by aggressive, I meant in ways of infrastructure. A stadium, coaching staff, equipment, etc. It feels "aggressive" that they'd have those in place by this summer.

Is it fair to assume that in 2025 they'd have a team comprised by majority underclassmen and walk-ons?

I wouldn't think hiring a coach and staff, procuring equipment and putting the beginning of a roster together (recruiting and transfer portal) would be prohibitive in a year. Not so for a stadium but I would think Calvin would have a few options that would at least get the program going before having something permanent in place.

HOPEful

Quote from: ziggy on October 31, 2022, 01:25:38 PM
I wouldn't think hiring a coach and staff, procuring equipment and putting the beginning of a roster together (recruiting and transfer portal) would be prohibitive in a year. Not so for a stadium but I would think Calvin would have a few options that would at least get the program going before having something permanent in place.

I agree, except I feel like many of that requires some firmer dates and guarantees, especially for the student athletes. I'd think recruiting would be quite difficult for a startup program. It would significantly more difficult without promises on when the first game/season would be...
Let's go Dutchmen!

2015-2016 1-&-Done Tournament Fantasy League Co-Champion

Pat Coleman

I'm sure they will be more forthcoming with student-athletes than they were in a high-level news release. The people I talked to seem pretty clear about 2025 being the start of varsity games.

As for recruiting student-athletes? A couple dozens schools have done so successfully in the past 25 years. It's work but it's doable:
https://www.d3football.com/interactive/faq/general#16

Publisher. Questions? Check our FAQ for D3f, D3h.
Quote from: old 40 on September 25, 2007, 08:23:57 PMLet's discuss (sports) in a positive way, sometimes kidding each other with no disrespect.

formerd3db

Calvin is not going to have a problem with recruiting. I also agree with Pat that a 2025 tentative start is anything but an aggressive start. There are many alums (and other people) who would prefer an earlier start to an official season, and it could be easily done. As far as a stadium, there are plenty of nearby high school stadiums that could easily be utilized, if they changed their minds about the initial start-up scenario. Regardless, you can be sure that there will be a huge (over capacity) crowd at that first Hope/Calvin football game whatever the date eventually is.
"When the Great Scorer comes To mark against your name, He'll write not 'won' or 'lost', But how you played the game." - Grantland Rice

KnightSlappy

#9864
Quote from: ziggy on October 31, 2022, 09:13:24 AM
Quote from: Bilk on October 30, 2022, 02:39:20 PM
Any chance the MIAA presidents/ ADs would allow Holland v. Calvin to end the season yearly?

Wow. Literally came to this board this morning to pose this exact question as it just came to mind. I come humbly to ask because I don't know anything about how the conference has handled scheduling or if it would have any intention of setting up Calvin-Hope football at the end of the season like Michigan-Ohio State. One of the interesting things about rivalries in college football is some have consistent traditional dates and some don't.

(I should also add that I don't take for granted that Calvin will create a football program out of nothing then quickly build a program that makes a final week rivalry game especially important beyond the rivalry itself.)

The MIAA hasn't seemed inclined to give any sort of scheduling preference or acknowledgement for the basketball rivalry*, which is as much of A ThingTM as there is in all of D3 athletics, so I doubt they'd allow anything 'special' for football.

*We'll be on our second-consecutive season of both Rivalry games occurring on Wednesday nights.

Flying Dutch Fan

Quote from: HOPEful on October 31, 2022, 11:57:03 AM
In all seriousness though, my mind immediately goes to financial questions regarding the move.

1. How long is reasonable to expect that the football program is in the black? A lot of effort and money is going to be put into making this happen, what's the expected payoff?


This lead to wonder, are there actually D3 schools that are in the black regarding a given sport?  I guess it depends on how you define it (enrollment boosts, etc.).
2016, 2020, 2022 MIAA Pick 'Em Champion

"Sports are kind of like passion and that's temporary in many cases, but academics - that's like true love and that's enduring." 
John Wooden

"Blame FDF.  That's the default.  Always blame FDF."
goodknight

HOPEful

Quote from: Flying Dutch Fan on November 03, 2022, 01:14:23 PM
This lead to wonder, are there actually D3 schools that are in the black regarding a given sport?  I guess it depends on how you define it (enrollment boosts, etc.).

Such a hard metric to nail down. If you count the cost of facilities, absolutely not. If you count just coaches, equipment, and travel... yes. But as you said with enrollment boosts, there are both more real costs and secondary benefits than those.

I'm sure Calvin will happily take on any and all additional costs if a football team gets more students to enroll.
Let's go Dutchmen!

2015-2016 1-&-Done Tournament Fantasy League Co-Champion

ziggy

Quote from: KnightSlappy on November 02, 2022, 09:57:35 PM
Quote from: ziggy on October 31, 2022, 09:13:24 AM
Quote from: Bilk on October 30, 2022, 02:39:20 PM
Any chance the MIAA presidents/ ADs would allow Holland v. Calvin to end the season yearly?

Wow. Literally came to this board this morning to pose this exact question as it just came to mind. I come humbly to ask because I don't know anything about how the conference has handled scheduling or if it would have any intention of setting up Calvin-Hope football at the end of the season like Michigan-Ohio State. One of the interesting things about rivalries in college football is some have consistent traditional dates and some don't.

(I should also add that I don't take for granted that Calvin will create a football program out of nothing then quickly build a program that makes a final week rivalry game especially important beyond the rivalry itself.)

The MIAA hasn't seemed inclined to give any sort of scheduling preference or acknowledgement for the basketball rivalry*, which is as much of A ThingTM as there is in all of D3 athletics, so I doubt they'd allow anything 'special' for football.

*We'll be on our second-consecutive season of both Rivalry games occurring on Wednesday nights.

Maybe there are some college rivalries tied to specific times of year but it seems to be more a college football thing and that is the perspective I was coming from. College football seems to stand alone in having some traditional slots for rivalries, like Michigan and Ohio State the last game of the season, Oklahoma and Texas playing the second weekend of October coinciding with the Texas State Fair, etc.

sac

Circling back to the two MIAA in the NCAA field thing, there is a path for 2 though I think its still pretty unlikely, there are only 4 Pool C bids available? Or is it 5?.   Albion is ranked #2, Alma #3 in the most recent rankings.   Albion's at large chances are probably better than Alma with a much better SOS, Alma will get a little help from playing unbeaten Albion, but a loss I think puts them in trouble for a bid.

In either case I think the loser probably stays ranked ahead of any of the other Region 7 likely Pool C's


Two in the playoffs is at least a possibility of some measure I can't put a % on, none of us thought one might be Alma.

sac

Logan Hanson on the twitterz who does a masterful job breaking down D3 football has Albion at 75% chance in with loss, Alma 56% with a loss
https://twitter.com/LogHanRatings

He seems pretty confident in two MIAA making the playoffs.