Pool B

Started by Ralph Turner, October 01, 2005, 02:12:36 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

DutchFan2004

So if I digested this all correctly,  the NWC does not have to get a pool B bid.  Some other conference could take two pool B bids and leave the NWC out?  Then the West may get an extra pool C bid such as taking and extra IIAC, WIAC, and MIAC team? So that these conferences would have 6 teams instead of the 5 they have gotten before.  I am not saying that these conferences are locks for them but using it as an example.  IIAC 1, WIAC 3, MIAC 2 or something of that nature.  But with the NWC beating each other up this is a possibility is it not?
Play with Passion  Coach Ron Schipper

Ralph Turner

#286
Yes, kinda.  There is no predetermined number of bids assigned to a region.

AS Pool C and Pool B teams start to come into focus, one can see how the teams are jockeying for the at-large bids.

Please go back to the Pool B and Pool C discussions that we had in the 7th -10th weeks of 2006.  :)

Pool B discussion in 2006

The IIAC just might get a Pool C bid this year.  I think that the chances of a Pool C bid for the WIAC are very good, if they don't knock each off.

K-Mack

Agree on both IIAC and WIAC. Maybe even MIAC if Olaf knocks off the Johnnies, or even if they don't.

The thing is, it all depends on how everyone stacks up relatively at the end of the year. Some years there will be a two-loss at-large lock, some years there will be one-loss teams a TD from being undefeated who don't stack up and sit home.

I'm sure there's a way for the NWC to still get two bids, if things fall into place and the UAA and ACFC beat on each other or have upsets. You never know.
Former author, Around the Nation ('01-'13)
Managing Editor, Kickoff
Voter, Top 25/Play of the Week/Gagliardi Trophy/Liberty Mutual Coach of the Year
Nastradamus, Triple Take
and one of the two voices behind the sonic #d3fb nerdery that is the ATN Podcast.

Bob.Gregg

After tomorrow's games, I'll put the skinny together on the contenders & pretenders in Pool B, as a public service to the Pool B, well, public...
Been wrong before.  Will be wrong again.

K-Mack

Former author, Around the Nation ('01-'13)
Managing Editor, Kickoff
Voter, Top 25/Play of the Week/Gagliardi Trophy/Liberty Mutual Coach of the Year
Nastradamus, Triple Take
and one of the two voices behind the sonic #d3fb nerdery that is the ATN Podcast.

d-train

Still going to be a while before the NWC sorts itself out. PLU and Linfield have a conference loss each; while Whitworth and Willamette each have one non-conference, regional D3 loss. Only two of the six total games among the four teams have been played...and there isn't one on the slate for this weekend.

repete

Last weekend really seemed to alter the West landscape quite a bit ...with the noteable exception of the NWC.

--WIAC carnage has started (with UWW above the fray). UWLX probably blew its season but will have a lot to say in whether the league gets a 2nd team in. I'm guessing a 2nd team might not work out. Life is tough and so is the WIAC ... (although there were some interesting comments by John O'Grady about UWW/SJU last weekend ...)

--If SJU and St. Olaf win out, it would be pretty hard to deny the Oles a spot. Bethel's stinker vs. BVU  means the Royals need to win out or get an unlikely combination of other Ole/Johnnie losses. The league's in pretty good shape for 2nd team, if Oles get it done but it's tough to see any 2-loss team getting in without the AQ.

-- IIAC could very well come down to last week of the season and if Wartburg loses that loss to the Auggies could sink them and leave Central as the lone rep.

--In the SCIAC, Oxy established itself as favorite but Cal Lutheran could shake up league. Will two teams come from here? Is Redlands a candidate if it wins out but misses the AQ?

Am I on the right path here?

d-train

Quote from: repete on October 08, 2007, 11:30:57 AM
Will two teams come from here? Is Redlands a candidate if it wins out but misses the AQ?

I normally wouldn't think of the SCIAC as a likely two-bid conference. But an 8-1 (well...7-1 vs. D3) Redlands team with a win at Whitworth could be fairly attractive (depending on the rest of the Pool C field, obviously). I would imagine that the Pirates final position in the NWC standings (or Regional Rankings) will impact the Bulldogs to some degree.

Bob.Gregg

Quote from: repete on October 08, 2007, 11:30:57 AM
Am I on the right path here?

You might be on the right path, repete, but not "here".

Other than the NWC note, none of the items listed are "Pool B" material...

But good info.
Been wrong before.  Will be wrong again.

repete

Yeah, Bob, I know. At times, these discussions muddle together.

I was reacting to KMack's note about possible multiple spots for  the IIAC, WIAC and MIAC. The discussion got sidetracked a bit before I came along... and ought to be in the Pool C talk.

Bob.Gregg

#295
Sorry this took so long, fellas.  For some reason, my boss thought I actually should be working the past two days....

Team (record/regional record)
Remaining Schedule (Regional Games in Bold)

Salisbury (6-0/5-0)  including win over Christopher Newport (35-21)
At Morrisville State
Becker
At Wesley
Frostburg State


Case Western Reserve (5-0/4-0)
At CMU
St. Vincent
At Chicago
Washington (MO)
Ohio Wesleyan


Wesley (5-1/5-1) including win over Delaware Valley (24-21), Loss to Montclair State (27-26)
At Newport News
At Brockport State
Salisbury
At Morrisville State

Whitworth (4-1/4-1) including win over Pac.Lutheran (28-21), Loss to Redlands, 24-12
At Lewis & Clark
At Azusa Pacific (non-NCAA)
At Willamette
Linfield
At Puget South


Pacific Lutheran (4-1/4-1) Loss to Whitworth, 28-21
Menlo
At Linfield
Lewis & Clark
Willamette


Washington (5-1/5-1) including win over North Central (16-13), Loss to Wheaton (55-14)
Chicago
At Carnegie-Mellon
At Case Western Reserve
At Greenville


Linfield (2-2/2-1) Loss to Willamette, 33-32, Loss to Western Ore., 32-20
At Southern Oregon (non-DIII)
Pacific Lutheran
At Menlo
At Whitworth
Lewis & Clark


Chicago (3-1/3-1) Loss to Elmhurst, 36-13
At Washington (MO)
Carnegie-Mellon
Case Western Reserve
At Northwestern (MN)
Eureka


Willamette (2-3/2-1) Loss to Gustavus Adolphus, 34-25, Loss Western Oregon, 23-9 (non-DIII), Loss to Southern Oregon, 34-27 (non-NCAA)
At Puget Sound
At Menlo
Whitworth
At Lewis & Clark
Pacific Lutheran



Been wrong before.  Will be wrong again.

Ralph Turner

#296
Quote from: Bob.Gregg on October 09, 2007, 09:00:35 PM
Sorry this took so long, fellas.  For some reason, my boss thought I actually should be working the past two days....

Team (record/regional record)
Remaining Schedule (Regional Games in Bold)

Salisbury (6-0/5-0)  including win over Christopher Newport (35-21)
At Morrisville State
Becker
At Wesley
Frostburg State


Case Western Reserve (5-0/4-0)
At CMU
St. Vincent
At Chicago
Washington (MO)

Ohio Wesleyan


Wesley (5-1/5-1) including win over Delaware Valley (24-21), Loss to Montclair State (27-26)
At Newport News
At Brockport State
Salisbury
At Morrisville State

Whitworth (4-1/4-1) including win over Pac.Lutheran (28-21), Loss to Redlands, 24-12
At Lewis & Clark
At Azusa Pacific (non-NCAA)
At Willamette
Linfield
At Puget South


Pacific Lutheran (4-1/4-1) Loss to Whitworth, 28-21
Menlo
At Linfield
Lewis & Clark
Willamette


Washington (5-1/5-1) including win over North Central (16-13), Loss to Wheaton (55-14)
Chicago
At Carnegie-Mellon
At Case Western Reserve
At Greenville


Linfield (2-2/2-1) Loss to Willamette, 33-32, Loss to Western Ore., 32-20
At Southern Oregon (non-DIII)
Pacific Lutheran
At Menlo
At Whitworth
Lewis & Clark


Chicago (3-1/3-1) Loss to Elmhurst, 36-13
At Washington (MO)
Carnegie-Mellon
Case Western Reserve
At Northwestern (MN)
Eureka




Games amongst "Pool B contenders" are in italics!

Thanks Bob!  +1 :)

Ron Boerger

I'm trying to figure out who keeps smiting Bob.  Whoever it is is one persistent SOB who probably needs to get a life.

d-train

#298
At this point, Willamette still has only one D3 loss. Wins over Linfield and Cal Lutheran with a loss to the Gusties. (Other losses to NAIA Southern Oregon and NCAA D2 Western Oregon). They don't look real strong at 2-3, but if the committee truly views that as 2-1 and they can play their way past Whitworth and PLU (both are home games for the Bearcats) then they are probably in at 7-1, right?

Bob.Gregg

#299
d-train,

You're thoughts on Willamette are right on.  They are part of the "rest of my list" (that's part of the reason I didn't do this until after 10/15 last year).

Willamette (2-3/2-1) Loss to Gustavus Adolphus, 34-25, Loss Western Oregon, 23-9 (non-DIII), Loss to Southern Oregon, 34-27 (non-NCAA)
At Puget Sound
At Menlo
Whitworth
At Lewis & Clark
Pacific Lutheran


Here's the rest of the "list"
Need lots of help:
Husson (4-2)
Martin Luther (4-2)
Rockford (4-2)

Been wrong before.  Will be wrong again.