FB: Region 3 fan poll

Started by Pat Coleman, June 23, 2008, 10:04:45 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Ralph Turner

South Region teams in the Top 25

#3 UMHB
#5 Wesley
#8 W&J

RV:
Trinity
Thomas More
Dickinson
HSC
Centre
LC
HSU
Miss Coll
Millsaps
CNU
Muhlenberg

DPU3619

Boy oh boy... is there some dissention among us about Trinity or what?

I also missed the Hardin-Simmons result, so you probably throw that one 4th place vote for them out the window. Ralph, do you want me to send you a different poll?

Toby Taff

The crazy thing about HSU is that injuries may take them completely out of contention for playoffs because the meat of the season is in the first 4 weeks of conference play: LC, MC, UMHB, ETBU.  If this seasons schedule had been reversed, the injuries might not have hurt them as badly.  The freshman QB might have been able to develop and be ready by the time those schools hit the schedule and the #4 would have remained appropriate.  I think that if HSU gets its rehab room cleared out, they may still end the season as a top 5 region team talent-wise, but I'm afraid the results from the first few weeks will tell a different story.
My wife and I are Alumni of both UMHB and HSU.  You think you are confused, my kids don't know which Purple and Gold team to pull for.

Ron Boerger

Quote from: Wes Anderson on September 21, 2009, 11:40:36 AM
Boy oh boy... is there some dissention among us about Trinity or what?

I also missed the Hardin-Simmons result, so you probably throw that one 4th place vote for them out the window. Ralph, do you want me to send you a different poll?

Really not that much given the struggles in the first two games and TU now being down to their #3 QB (who did look surprisingly good on Saturday).   Good matchup in Jackson should tell us about both Millsaps and Trinity.   

Am surprised that only one voter has 3-0 Centre when three still have DPU.   

Ralph Turner

Quote from: Wes Anderson on September 21, 2009, 11:40:36 AM
Boy oh boy... is there some dissention among us about Trinity or what?

I also missed the Hardin-Simmons result, so you probably throw that one 4th place vote for them out the window. Ralph, do you want me to send you a different poll?
Yes, that is fair.

There is so much question about the #4- #43 of the South Region that I did not doubt you.

If Feaster's shoulder heals, then he might be back for the UMHB game and we would be looking at a potential three-way tie, again.

DPU3619

Quote from: Ron Boerger on September 21, 2009, 12:13:08 PM
Am surprised that only one voter has 3-0 Centre when three still have DPU.   

I went back and forth about 4 times on that.  Couldn't really drop DPU from 4 to all the way out of the poll, considering I still think they're still going to be fine.  Bad games probably shouldn't happen to an elite quarterback like Spud, but one did and it cost them the game.  If he keeps playing like that though, there's going to be big trouble ahead.

Ralph Turner

#261
Week #3 Fan Poll  (Revised)



Team....................VotesRecordBallotsNext foe
1) UMHB502-01,1,1,1,1McMurry
2) Wesley453-02,2,2,2,2at LaGrange
3) W&J403-03,3,3,3,3at Grove City
4) HSC283-04,4,5,7,7at Guilford
5)  Dickinson203-04,5,7,8,xMcDaniel
6)  Trinity193-04,5,6,10,xat Millsaps
7)   Mississippi Coll.172-15,6,7,9,xHardin-Simmons
8 )  CNU151-15,6,9,9,xat Wilkes
9)   TMC122-06,8,8,10,xat Westminster PA
10)  La Coll72-04,x,x,x,xat Huntingdon
*****
RV)  DPU51-18,10,10,x,xat Sewanee
RV)  Millsaps52-16,x,x,x,xTrinity
RV)  Centre43-07,x,x,x,xAustin
RV)  E&H33-09,10,x,x,xat Methodist
RV)  Huntingdon32-18,x,x,x,xLouisiana College
RV)  HSU22-19,x,x,x,xat Miss Coll



Corrections appreciated.  Thanks to Hawks88 and to SaintsFan.

PA_wesleyfan

 I agree on the head to head with between Depauw and Centre.  I am not sold on CNU though.  Salisbury was without Sheahin at QB but Tunde didn't play for CNU. The extra week had to have helped CNU. I have been told that Wilkes is very good fundamentally and that will test CNU's D. If more undefeated teams continue to fall the south will become more of a puzzle. There are a number of teams that are bunched in talent and with teams suprising one week and then losing the next it could be very interesting to the end!
Football !!! The ultimate team sport. Anyone who plays DIII football is a winner...

SaintsFAN

Ralph,

Thomas More is only 2-0.  The were off in Week 2, after beating John Carroll. 
AMC Champs: 1991-1992-1993-1994-1995
HCAC Champs: 2000, 2001
PAC Champs:  2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016
Bridge Bowl Champs:  1990-1991-1992-1993-1994-1995-2002-2003-2006-2008-2009-2010-2011-2012-2013 (SERIES OVER)
Undefeated: 1991, 1995, 2001, 2009, 2010, 2015
Instances where MSJ quit the Bridge Bowl:  2

hasanova

I've got Centre on my watch list as well.  Centre vs DePauw will reveal a lot!

Ron Boerger

Quote from: hasanova on September 24, 2009, 11:23:14 AM
I've got Centre on my watch list as well.  Centre vs DePauw will reveal a lot!

Umm ...

Centre knocks off #20 Depauw, 34-24 (9-19-2009)

@d3jason

Quote from: Ron Boerger on September 24, 2009, 12:13:07 PM
Quote from: hasanova on September 24, 2009, 11:23:14 AM
I've got Centre on my watch list as well.  Centre vs DePauw will reveal a lot!

Umm ...

Centre knocks off #20 Depauw, 34-24 (9-19-2009)
It will be interesting to see how Centre follows that big win up against Austin this week. Trinity @ Millsaps should be a good one too.

HSC85

If Milsaps beats Trinity do you think that will move them both up in the poll or do you think they will be in the 8 - 10 range?

Ralph Turner

#268
Week #3 Fan Poll  (Revised to reflect 9/26 games)



Team....................VotesRecord thru 9-19Ballots9/26
1) UMHB502-01,1,1,1,1Beat McMurry 41-8
2) Wesley453-02,2,2,2,2Won at LaGrange, 56-7
3) W&J403-03,3,3,3,3Won at Grove City, 26-10
4) HSC283-04,4,5,7,7Won at Guilford, 31-6
5)  Dickinson203-04,5,7,8,xBeat McDaniel, 35-7
6)  Trinity193-04,5,6,10,xLost at Millsaps, 24-6
7)   Mississippi Coll.172-15,6,7,9,xBeat Hardin-Simmons, 39-34
8 )  CNU151-15,6,9,9,xLost at Wilkes 24-17
9)   TMC122-06,8,8,10,xWon at Westminster PA,
10)  La Coll72-04,x,x,x,xLost at Huntingdon, 34-21
*****
RV)  DPU51-18,10,10,x,xWon at Sewanee, 3-0
RV)  Millsaps52-16,x,x,x,xBeat Trinity, 24-6
RV)  Centre43-07,x,x,x,xBeat Austin, 34-27
RV)  E&H33-09,10,x,x,xWon at Methodist, 28-3
RV)  Huntingdon32-18,x,x,x,xBeat Louisiana College, 34-21
RV)  HSU 22-19,x,x,x,xLost at Miss Coll, 39-34



Corrections appreciated.  Thanks to Hawks88 and to SaintsFan.

Ralph Turner

I have four of the five ballots and only 12 teams have received votes.

Eight teams are on every ballot.

It is getting clearer.